Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCC Minutes 2019-11-13 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Cathedral City Study Session Wednesday, November 13, 2019 3:00 PM City Council Chambers 68-700 Avenida Lalo Guerrero Cathedral City, CA 92234 • CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order at 3:00 PM by Mayor Mark Carnevale. • ROLL CALL Attendee Name Title Status Arrived Mark Carnevale Mayor Present 3:00 PM John Aguilar Mayor Pro Tern Present 3:00 PM Raymond Gregory Councilmember Present 3:00 PM Ernesto Gutierrez Councilmember Present 3:00 PM Rita Lamb Councilmember Absent A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Aguilar and seconded by Councilmember Gregory to excuse the absence of Councilmember Rita Lamb from the November 13, 2019, Study Session Meeting. RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: John Aguilar, Mayor Pro Tern SECONDER: Raymond Gregory, Councilmember AYES: Mark Carnevale, John Aguilar, Raymond Gregory, Ernesto Gutierrez ABSENT: Rita Lamb 1. THE CITY COUNCIL WILL CONDUCT INTERVIEWS AT 3:00 PM A. Interview Applicants for the Historical Preservation Committee Recommendation: To interview the applicants that have submitted applications for possible appointment to fill five vacant seats on the Historical Preservation Committee. Charles McClendon, City Manager, announced that Michael Hagedorn and Dirk van Sloten, M.S. were unable to attend the meeting and participate in the interviews, however, they both wished to be considered for an appointment. The following individuals were interviewed by the City Council for the Historical Preservation Committee vacancies: John Rivera Andee Steinman Ilse Hernandez The City Council will make appointments to the Historical Preservation Committee during the regular meeting on November 13, 2019. Mayor Mark Carnevale announced at 3:40 p.m. that the City Council will take a brief recess and reconvene at 4:00 p.m. The City Council reconvened at 4:00 p.m. 2. CLOSED SESSION Eric Vail, City Attorney, announced that the City Council will meet in Closed Session to discuss the following items listed on the agenda. A. Conference with Legal Counsel - Anticipated Litigation Pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(d)(2). Number of Potential Cases: One B. Conference with Labor Negotiator Pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.6 Agency Negotiator: Charles McClendon, City Manager Represented Employees: AFSCME - The American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees CCPOA - Cathedral City Police Officers Association CCPMA - Cathedral City Police Management Association CCPFA - Cathedral City Firefighters Association CCFMA - Cathedral City Fire Management Association The City Council recessed to Closed Session at 4:00 p.m. The City Council reconvened at 4:30 p.m. Eric Vail, City Attorney, announced that the City Council met in Closed Session to discuss item 2A. Conference with Legal Counsel for one case and item 28. Conference with Labor Negotiator with AFSCME, CCPOA, CCPMA, CCPFA and CCFMA. There was no reportable action taken. • AGENDA FINALIZATION • STATEMENT OF PARTICIPATION BY THE CITY CLERK Cathedral City Page 2 Printed on 12/19/2019 3. PUBLIC COMMENT Steven Vogelsang, Cathedral City resident, was called to speak. He expressed his concern with the lack of animal control in the City. He stated that he has a problem with stray animals in his neighborhood. He questioned if all residents on Tortuga Road have connected to sewer and if not, have they been fined as the City indicated they would be years ago. Bob Hargreaves, Cathedral City resident, was called to speak. He expressed his concern with the short-term vacation rental behind his home. He provided pictures and the advertisement for the property which he feels is in violation of the current regulations. Doug Evans, Cathedral City resident, was called to speak. He thanked the City Council for the private security contract and for hiring a new Code Enforcement Manager, he has seen a difference already. It is his hope that the City Council will give clear direction to Staff and he encourages no warnings with more citations and fines. He feels itis time to get serious and their neighbors need help. 4. STUDY SESSION A. Greater Palm Springs Convention & Visitors Bureau Annual Update Recommendation: This is a presentation only. There is no formal action required. Scott White, President and CEO, Greater Palm springs Convention & Visitors Bureau, presented the CVB's annual update, marketing efforts and initiatives for Cathedral City. Mayor Mark Carnevale questioned the following: Can the cannabis industry be incorporated into their marketing? Has the CVB considered changing the name to Greater Coachella Valley Convention and Visitors Bureau? What it the most popular attraction in the valley? Scott White responded that they are limited to what they can do with regard to the cannabis industry, however, they do incorporate all that they can in their marketing. As far as the name of the CVB, they do testing annually on the name as well as each season. Greater Palm Springs still comes out ahead, for now. He stated that outdoor health and wellness is the most popular attraction in the valley as well as the events. Mayor Pro Tem Aguilar asked about training programs for hospitality workers. Scott White responded that there are many collaborations in place with the local colleges for training in the hospitality industry. Councilmember Ernesto Gutierrez questioned if they will be working with the cities regarding short term vacation rentals. He also asked for a status update on the flights from Palm Springs to Sacramento. Cathedral City Page 3 Printed on 12/19/2019 Scott White responded that CVB is exploring the possibility of a tax, which would have to be a collaboration with the CVB and local cities. He does not anticipate anything happening for another year or so. He stated that the flight from Palm Springs to Sacramento is doing very well. Councilmember Raymond Gregory, thanked Mr. White for his update. Alan Carvalho, Cathedral City resident, was called to speak. He stated that the presentation was awesome. He indicated that he likes the Mayor's idea to change CVB's name. B. Update from the Cannabis Task Force Recommendation: This item is presented for information, discussion and direction only. City Manager Charles McClendon presented an overview of the Cannabis Task Force Meeting that was held on October 28, 2019. After some discussion and clarification on the items presented by the City Manager on behalf of the Cannabis Task Force, it was the consensus of the City Council to direct staff to work on developing language pertaining to a parking standard, related to occupancy, that can be applied when a retail cannabis business seeks a license amendment to add a consumption lounge, for Council's consideration. It was also the consensus of the City Council to agendize a Study Session item on a future agenda for an overview of cannabis taxes and to include the discussion of distribution taxes. C. Street Sign Blade Topper Policy Recommendation: This item is presented for information, discussion and direction only. John Corella, Director of Engineering/Public Works, presented a proposed Street Sign Blade Topper Policy. Councilmember Raymond Gregory requested clarification of what the fee is for the application process when requesting street sign blade toppers. He suggested that staff prepare an analysis showing the actual costs of the application process. He also suggested that the policy state there is an option for the applicant to provide the street sign blade topper, based on the required specifications, or have the city purchase the sign and the applicant pays the City for the sign. He stated that he does not want this policy to affect the student sign program that is currently in place. Mayor Pro Tern John Aguilar clarified that applicants requesting a street sign blade topper would have to pay for it themselves with the exception of when the Public Arts Commission recommends the purchase and installation of street blades to honor a late artist. These street blades would be paid for out of the Public Arts fund. Cathedral City Page 4 Printed on 12/19/2019 Councilmember Ernesto Gutierrez questioned how the application process will work and feels that uniformity of signs is important. He also feels that there should be support of the residents for the requested street sign blade toppers. Mr. Corella provided an overview of the application process. It was the consensus of the City Council to direct staff to bring back a policy that includes the items discussed by the City Council along with proposed fees. Steve Vogelsang, Cathedral City resident, was called to speak. He feels the color schemes should differ from other city color schemes. Alan Carvalho, Cathedral City resident, was called to speak. He stated that he agrees with Councilmember Gutierrez about uniformity of the signs, with some exceptions like Candy Cane Lane. He feels the intention of the Public Arts Commission is to honor artists of the past and uniformity and conformity is important when moving forward. D. Grant Opportunities for Streets, Flood Control and Parks. Recommendation: Presentation, discussion, costs and urgency issues associated with current grant opportunities and applications along with recommendations from Staff on which grants the City Council may be interested in pursuing. Included in this discussion are proposed CVAG - ATP related design engineering grant opportunities that will be presented at the City Council meeting next month for approval. John Corella, Director of Engineering and Public Works, began presenting potential grant opportunities for streets, flood control and parks. Mayor Mark Carnevale announced that the City Council will take a brief recess and Mr. Corella will continue with his presentation at the end of the Regular City Council Meeting of November 13, 2019. ADJOURN Mayor Mark Carnevale adjourned the Study Session Meeting of November 13, 2019, at 6:25 p.m. 2 A . M r, City of edral City City Clerk,rity of athedral Ci Cathedral City Page 5 Printed on 12/19/2019 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Cathedral City Regular Meeting Wednesday, December 11 , 2019 6:30 PM City Council Chambers 68-700 Avenida Lalo Guerrero Cathedral City, CA 92234 • CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order at 6:30 PM by Councilmember Mark Carnevale. • PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Councilmember Raymond Gregory led the Pledge of Allegiance. • INVOCATION (MOMENT OF REFLECTION) Councilmember Ernesto Gutierrez offered the Invocation. • ROLL CALL Mayor Carnevale thanked his wife for all her support and his son for running the family business while he tended to City business. He thanked his fellow Council Members and Staff for all their support and help during his term as Mayor. He expressed his gratitude for the staff members that always answered his phone calls even on weekends and holidays. He stated that he will continue to make decisions for the good of the City as he continues to serve on City Council. He feels Cathedral City is going to have a great future ahead of them with John Aguilar as Mayor and Raymond Gregory as Mayor Pro Tem. He thanked Fire Chief Wilson and Police Chief Yoakum for all that they do. He also thanked his friends and everyone for being here. Attendee Name Title Status Arrived Mark Carnevale . Councilmember i_Present 6:30 PM John Aguilar Mayor Present 6:30 PM Raymond Gregory Mayor Pro Tem Present 6:30 PM Ernesto Gutierrez Councilmember Present 6:30 PM Rita Lamb Councilmember Present 6:30 PM • AGENDA FINALIZATION • MAYOR AND MAYOR PRO TEM APPOINTMENT/OATH OF OFFICE A. Appointment of Mayor and Mayor Pro Tern Recommendation: To appoint, in accordance with Section 2.04.180 of the Municipal Code, John Aguilar to serve as Mayor for a one year term through the first Council meeting in December 2020; and to appoint Raymond Gregory to serve as Mayor Pro Tem for the same term. A motion was made by Councilmember Gutierrez and seconded by Councilwoman Lamb to approve the To appoint, in accordance with Section 2.04.180 of the Municipal Code, John Aguilar to serve as Mayor for a one year term through the first Council meeting in December 2020; and to appoint Raymond Gregory to serve as Mayor Pro Tem for the same term. RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Ernesto Gutierrez, Councilmember SECONDER: Rita Lamb, Councilmember AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb • SWEAR-IN APPOINTED MAYOR AND MAYOR PRO TEM City Clerk, Tracey Martinez, swore in John Aguilar as the newly appointed Mayor and Raymond Gregory as the newly appointed Mayor Pro Tern. • 10 MINUTE RECESS The City Council recessed at 6:43 pm. The City Council reconvened at 6:53 pm. Mayor John Aguilar thanked Mark Carnevale for the incredible job he did as Mayor this past year leading the Council through some difficult circumstances and through achieving many mile stones. He looks forward to continuing to work with Mark and the rest of the Council in this next year. He is excited about the upcoming year and feels lucky to have such an incredible staff and all of their support. He gave a special thanks to his husband Bruce for being his constant support for 25 years. He thanked his many close friends for their support and advice. He also thanked former Mayor Stan Henry and wife Julie for what they have done and continue to do for the community and for their support. He thanked many others in attendance, including his childhood friend Kris and his Mother-in-law Joan who is an amazing woman. Mayor John Aguilar gave a special presentation of recognition for former Mayor Mark Carnevale and Mrs. Carnevale. Antonio Lopez and Richard Altman, Cathedral City Gay Business Association, presented an award of appreciation to former Mayor Mark Carnevale and Cathedral City Page 2 Printed on 12/19/2019 Mrs. Carnevale in recognition of their support to the Cathedral City Gay Business Association. Fire Chief Paul Wilson presented an award of appreciation to former Mayor Mark Carnevale on behalf of the Cathedral City Fire Department. Councilmember Ernesto Gutierrez thanked Councilmember Mark Carnevale for stepping up to the plate in a minutes notice and doing an amazing job. He congratulated Mayor John Aguilar and stated that he has his support. Councilmember Rita Lamb congratulated Mayor John Aguilar and thanked him for the support and welcome he gave her when she joined the City Council. His leadership is inspiring and she is proud to represent Cathedral City and work with everyone. Mayor Pro Tem Raymond Gregory stated that former Mayor Mark Carnevale was able to work through and rise above to become a great Mayor this past year and appreciates his leadership and is proud to serve with him. He looks forward to continuing to server with Mayor John Aguilar this year and feels he is a great guy. He feels Mayor Aguilar has shown through the years his passion and experience translates to good things for Cathedral City. He stated that he feels honored and thanked everyone, pledging to continue to work for them. Councilmember Mark Carnevale feels at home and congratulated Mayor John Aguilar and Mayor Pro Tem Raymond Gregory. • STATEMENT OF PARTICIPATION BY THE CITY CLERK 1. PUBLIC COMMENT Teri Hargreaves, Cathedral City resident, was called to speak. Congratulated Mayor Aguilar and Mayor Pro Tem Raymond Gregory. Medical issues for a resident who lives Candy Cane Lane Grandma Al, Fire Department helped put up her Christmas decorations, wonderful thing and thanked the them they are very appreciative. Wished everyone happy holiday. Kathleen DeRosa, Cathedral City resident, was called to speak. She congratulated Mayor Aguilar and Mayor Pro Tern Gregory and welcomed them to their new roles. She wanted to publicly recognize and thank Mark Carnevale for his work as Mayor during the last year and feels he brought class and dignity back to the City. She feels this City Council is cohesive with the best interests of the City at heart and wished them well. Beverly Greer, Neuro Vitality Center, was called to speak. She announced that they are now licensed by the State for full adult care and as of the new year they will be accepting new patients with memory problems. Judy Norman, La Quinta resident, was called to speak. She spoke about the Salton Sea and thanked the City Council for their support of ocean water import. She asked Cathedral City Page 3 Printed on 12/19/2019 that the City Council send letters in support of the emergency declaration to make funding available for the Salton Sea issued by Imperial County. David Boughner, Cathedral City resident, was called to speak. He is a swimmer and is supportive of the City utilizing the Cathedral City High School pool for public use. He stated that this is a step in the right direction and would like to see the pool utilized year around. Jens Mueller, Cathedral City resident, was called to speak. He stated that Mark Carnevale did the City proud. He spoke about short-term vacation rentals and urged the City Council to follow the Palm Desert model and phase them out. Doug Evans, Cathedral City resident, was called to speak. He thanked former Mayor Mark Carnevale for doing a great job and he is confident that the City has a great Council. He discussed neighborhoods and the problems with short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods. 2. COUNCIL REPORTS Councilmember Rita Lamb stated that she appreciates the sense of community that has been mentioned tonight. She reported that she attended the Boys and Girls Club fundraiser, toured the Museum of Ancient Wonders, the Cathedral City High School D.A.T.A. Demonstration Day and the Date Palm Country Club golf cart parade. She also attended two Desert Community Energy meetings and looks forward to attending the Snowfest event and the Emily West concert. Councilmember Ernesto Gutierrez reported that he attended the CVAG committee, the CVAP economic update, a meeting with representatives from T-Mobile, the Palm Springs Convention of Vistors b meeting, boys and girls gala fundraiser, DPCC golf cart, met with City Manager Charles McClendon to go over the Agenda, met with residents. He announced that North Gate Church will be having a Christmas concert with singers from Cathedral City High School on December 14, 2019 at 4:00 pm and everyone is invited. Councilmember Mark Carnevale reported that he attended the CVAG Homeless committee meeting. Path of life ministry. Mayor Pro Tem Raymond Gregory reported that he attended the fundraiser at the Senior Center. Fire Department Event at Panorama Park. Committee assignment meetings. transgender day of remembrance. northgate church girl scout group spoke about city government. Balloon Festival was a great event. attended the RCTC twice since the last meeting. continues to be a lot of work. City Hall in your corner. Movie in the park coming up 12-28. Attended the Boys and Girls Club. SunLine. Bluelight ceremony. Snowfest is coming up this weekend. Mayor John Aguilar attended many of the same events. Saturday Desert Memorial Park, daughters ...wreaths across america event. Monday 12/23 rabi annual hanaka. 3. CONSENT AGENDA Cathedral City Page 4 Printed on 12/19/2019 A motion was made by Councilmember Carnevale and seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Gregory to approve the following Consent Agenda items: RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Mark Carnevale, Councilmember SECONDER: Raymond Gregory, Mayor Pro Tern AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb A. Minutes Approval M.O. 2019-152 1. City Council - Study Session - Nov 13, 2019 3:00 PM 2. City Council - Regular Meeting - Nov 13, 2019 6:30 PM B. Receive and file Payment of Claims and Demands for November 2019 Recommendation: The City Council acting in its capacity for the City, the Successor Agency to the former Redevelopment Agency, the Housing Successor Agency, and the Cathedral City Public Finance Authority Board receive and file payment of claims and demands in the aggregate sum of $5,849,829 for the month of November 2019. M.O. 2019-153 C. California Government Code Section 50075 Report, Community Facilities District (CFD) 2006-1) Recommendation: To accept the FY 18/19 California Government Code Section 50075 report for CFD 2006-1 revenues and expenditures. M.O. 2019-154 D. Council Appointments to Various Local Agencies for 2020 Recommendation: Staff recommends the City Council review the list of Local Agency Assignments and make the appointments. M.O. 2019-155 E. 1902 pulled from Consent F. Purchase of a Replacement 2020 Ford Pick-up for the Fire Department Recommendation: To authorize staff to purchase one 2020 Ford F250 pick-up, including sales tax and delivery, from Palm Springs Ford for a total cost of$35,369.40 M.O. 2019-157 G. Grant of Easements to SCE on City-Owned Park Lots in the Rio Vista (Verano) Development Recommendation: To approve Grants of Easement to Southern California Edison (SCE) for utility easements on City-owned park Lots 271 , 272, 287 and 288 of Tract 28639-1, in the Rio Vista Cathedral City Page 5 Printed on 12/19/2019 (Verano) development; and, authorize the City Manager to execute the Grants of Easement on behalf of the City. M.O. 2019-158 H. Resolutions Certifying the Completion of Private Improvements in Tracts 34322-1 and 34322 Recommendation: To approve Resolutions certifying the completion of private improvements within Tract 34322-1 and Tract 34322, each; and, authorize the release of Improvement Agreement securities and deposits as described in the Resolutions; and, authorize the Director of Engineering/Public Works to file Notices of Completion on each Tract. Reso 2019-42 Reso 2019-43 I. Resolution Accepting an Offer of Dedication for Public Street Purposes of a Portion of Lot "P" of Palm Springs Country Club Estates, for the North Side of Ramon Road, East of San Luis Rey. Recommendation: To approve a Resolution accepting the offer of dedication for public street purposes of a portion of Lot "P" as shown on the map of Palm Springs Country Club Estates, for a portion of the north side of Ramon Road, east of San Luis Rey. Reso 2019-44 J. Resolution of Intention to Vacate certain streets, alleys, easements and reserved utility easements in the area north of East Palm Canyon Drive, west of Date Palm Drive, east of Monty hall Avenue and south of Buddy Rogers Avenue. Vacation No. 2019-01. Recommendation: To adopt a Resolution declaring the City's intention to vacate all or portions of Hillery Road (formerly First Street) and Grove Street, between Monty Hall Drive and Allen Avenue; a public alley between Hillery Road and Grove Street; two sidewalk easements on the north side of Grove Street; and, various utility easements reserved from the previous vacation of other portions of Hillery Road, Grove Street, Dawes Street, Allen Avenue, and public alleys, and easements for street and highway purposes, all as described in City Council Resolutions No. 2015-49-A and No. 2017- 11-A, both recorded on August 10, 2017, as instruments No. 2017-0330780 and 0330781, in Official Records, all located in the northwest quadrant of Date Palm Drive and East Palm Canyon Drive, east of Monty Hall Drive and south of Buddy Rogers Avenue. Reso 2019-45 K. Contract Award to CASC Engineering and Consulting, Inc. for NPDES Program Consulting Services Recommendation: To award a two-year, on-call contract to CASC Engineering and Consulting, Inc. for National Pollutant Discharge Cathedral City Page 6 Printed on 12/19/2019 Elimination System (NPDES) Program Consulting Services; and, authorize the City Manager to execute the contact documents; and, authorize the Director of Engineering/Public Works to issue Task Orders as needed to complete the NPDES Program requirements within existing FY 2020-21 budget limits. M.O. 2019-159 L. Second Reading of Temporary Cannabis Event Ordinance Recommendation: To provide second reading and adopt an Ordinance amending Section 5.88.035 of the Cathedral City Municipal Code related to temporary cannabis events. Ord 829 M. American Forensic Nurses Agreement Approval Recommendation: To enter into an agreement with American Forensic Nurses for on-call nursing services and authorize the City Manager to execute the agreement documents. M.O. 2019-160 N. Expenditure Plan for the Supplemental Law Enforcement Services Account (SLESA) for FY 2018-2019 Recommendation: To approve the recommended Expenditure Plan appropriating a portion of the Supplemental Law Enforcement Service Account (SLESA) for FY 2018-2019 M.O. 2019-161 O. Police Chief Recruitment Recommendation: To authorize a Budget Amendment in the amount of$25,000 for executive recruitment for a Police Chief. M.O. 2019-162 4. ITEMS PULLED FROM CONSENT A. STVR Data Analytics Services Recommendation: To ratify the award of a contract to Deckard Technologies for STVR data analytics services and authorize the required budget amendment in the amount of$14,000. Henry Bagumyan, Las Angeles resident and Cathedral City short-term vacation rental owner, was called to speak. He stated that he had a general comment about short-term vacation rentals. He stated that Cathedral City has been a second home to him, so he decided to by a home here to be able to visit as well as a business opportunity. He has been in compliance with the City and gets along with his neighbors. He suggested the City interview applicants to see what their intents are and provide the City Council with before and after pictures of his property. He inquired on how he can help resolve the problems and move the process forward. Cathedral City Page 7 Printed on 12/19/2019 M.O. 2019-156 A motion was made by Councilmember Gutierrez and seconded by Councilmember Carnevale to approve the To ratify the award of a contract to Deckard Technologies for STVR data analytics services and authorize the required budget amendment in the amount of$14,000. RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Ernesto Gutierrez, Councilmember SECONDER: Mark Carnevale, Councilmember AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb 5. PUBLIC HEARINGS A. Second Amendment to the 2017 Tax Sharing Agreement with Palm Springs Motors, Inc. Recommendation: To hold a public hearing; approve a Resolution approving a second revised tax sharing report for Palm Springs Motors; and authorize the City Manager and City Attorney to negotiate and prepare, and authorize the City Manager to execute, a second amendment to the tax sharing agreement with Palm Springs Motors, Inc., consistent with the terms set forth in the Resolution. Stone James, Economic Development Director presented an overview of the second amendment to the 2017 Tax Sharing Agreement with Palm Springs Motor, Inc. He introduced Greg Olsen Greg Olsen, Attorney representing Palm Springs Motors, was called to speak. He offered to answer any questions from the Council. Mayor John Aguilar opened the Public Hearing. Mayor John Aguilar closed the Public Hearing. Mayor Pro Tem Raymond Gregory thanked Stone James for the work that he put into the item. He thanked Palm Springs Motors for working with Staff to make this happen. Reso 2019-46 M.O. 2019-163 A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Gregory and seconded by Councilmember Gutierrez to approve the To hold a public hearing; approve a Resolution approving a second revised tax sharing report for Palm Springs Motors; and authorize the City Manager and City Attorney to negotiate and prepare, and authorize the City Manager to execute, a second amendment to the tax sharing agreement with Palm Springs Motors, Inc., consistent with the terms set forth in the Resolution. Cathedral City Page 8 Printed on 12/19/2019 RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Raymond Gregory, Mayor Pro Tem SECONDER: Ernesto Gutierrez, Councilmember AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb B. De novo review of Conditional Use Permit No. 19-008 issued by the Cathedral City Planning Commission. Recommendation: It is requested that the Mayor and City Council Members conduct a public hearing to consider a de novo review of Planning Commission approval of Conditional Use Permit No. 19-008 to allow a Congregate Living Health Facility for up to 12 beds within an existing single family residential dwelling in the R1 Zoning District. Eric Vail, City Attorney, presented the City Council with the following information on Congregate Living Health Facilities (CLHF): • What is a Congregate Living Health Facility? • State Comprehensive Licensing System • State Law Standards for CLHF Licensing • State Law Preemption/Limitation on Local Regulation of CLHFs Councilmember Ernesto Gutierrez confirmed that if a CLHF wants to change from a 6-bed to a 12-bed facility it would require a Conditional Use Permit (CUP). He also inquired if the City can impose requirements for room size dimensions. City Attorney Vail responded that a CLHF would require a CUP to change from a 6-bed to a 12-bed facility. He also responded that the City can impose requirements to the extent of the standards that are imposed on single family dwellings. He advised the Council that they should try and act within the limits and standards allowed by State law. Councilmember Rita Lamb confirmed that this facility is currently an existing 6- bed facility. She also inquired if the State verifies the facility meets State requirements before or after City Council makes their decisions, and what the process is if the facility does not meet the State's requirements. City Attorney Vail responded that the Facility is currently licensed as a 6-bed facility. He explained the process of when the State verifies that the facility meets the State requirements and the subsequent steps if it does not meet those requirements. Councilmember Ernesto Gutierrez inquired on the purpose of having a CUP. City Attorney Vail responded that a CUP is what is required by the City to allow the City to have a way to regulate. Mayor John Aguilar inquired whether the presentation provided by the City Attorney was also presented to the Planning Commission. Cathedral City Page 9 Printed on 12/19/2019 I Brenda Ramirez, Associate Planner, responded that the City Attorney's presentation was not presented to the Planning Commission. She presented the Staff's review of Conditional Use Permit No. 19-008. The following points were presented: • Conditional Use Permit • City's Evaluation of Project • Project Proposal • Project Location/Existing Site • State Requirements/Site Visit • Facility Details • R1 Zoning Ordinance/Compliance Requirements Needed • Staff Recommendation Councilmember Ernesto Gutierrez asked for further clarification on the purpose of having CUPs. He also inquired if the owners of the facility will hire employees and if the City is allowing these facilities to operate as a business in residential areas. Robert Rodriguez, Planning Director, responded that the conditional use permit process allows the City to review and apply any conditions to mitigate any concerns the City has. He stated that the applicants are owner/operators and will hire employees which is required by law. City Attorney Vail responded that under State Law CLHFs are considered single family homes, and the law is specific to only CLHFs. Robert Rodriguez clarified the requirements for bedroom dimensions. Brenda Ramirez stated that there are no patients currently in the facility and the facility has been licensed for over six months. Councilmember Ernesto Gutierrez stated that he feels there is not sufficient room or privacy for the residents in the facility. He feels there are a few issues that need to be worked out. Councilmember Mark Carnevale inquired if the facility meets all the State's and City's regulations. He also inquired about parking, kitchen specifications and accommodations for staff. Brenda Ramirez responded that facility has met both State and City requirements. She gave an overview of the kitchen, food preparation and the staff accommodations. Mayor John Aguilar opened the Public Hearing. Levon Akhsharumov, Applicant, was called to speak. He offered to answer any questions that the City Council may have. Cathedral City Page 10 Printed on 12/19/2019 Councilmember Ernesto Gutierrez inquired about the number of employees that will staff the facility. Mr. Akhsharumov responded that there will be 3 employees on duty per 8-hour shift and other staff will be on duty as needed. Councilmember Mark Carnevale inquired if there will be any commercial deliveries or if everything be done in house. Mr. Akhsharumov responded that everything will be done in house. Mayor Pro Tem Raymond Gregory inquired on the owners plans to landscape as required by the City. Mr. Akhsharumov gave a brief overview of the plan to landscape as outlined on the presented drawing. Susan Cubine, Cathedral City resident, was called to speak. She lives next door to the facility and feels that hazardous waste will be generated from this facility which needs to be addressed. She feels that 12 beds will be pushing the limits. She expressed her concern with the size of the bedrooms at the property. Krystal Franz-Wilson, Cathedral City resident, was called to speak. She expressed her concern with the landscaping at the property and the fact that no one is ever on the property. She is also concerned with who will be hired and who will be the advocate. Mayor John Aguilar asked if there were any more members of the public that wish to speak. Seeing none, he closed the Public Hearing. Mayor Pro Tem Raymond Gregory thanked the Council and Staff for taking the time to review this CUP. He also thanked the City Attorney for his clarifications. He feels that when an applicant applies for a CUP for a CLHF, it is reasonable for the City to review and determine if the facility qualifies as a CLHF. He feels many of the concerns of the residents have to do with having the quality of the facility. He feels the facility appears to qualify through the State as a CLHF, and the City Council does not have the ability to limit that. He inquired if it is appropriate for the City Council to pass along their concerns to the other licensing agencies. City Attorney Vail responded that the State law does not hinder the Council's ability to express their concerns and the Council can send letters of concern to the appropriate agencies. He reaffirmed as phrased by the Planning Departments the applicant must provide the City a copy of their State license prior to occupancy. If the applicant should fail to do so, the City has the policing right to seek to revoke the CUP or pursue other code enforcement activities. He stated that section 1.6 condition of approval will require the applicant be able to be served appropriately by all utilities including Burtec for waste disposal. If the City were to find that there is an accumulation of hazardous or toxic waste the City would have available their Code Enforcement mechanisms. Councilmember Rita Lamb expressed her concerns with the size of the facility Cathedral City Page 11 Printed on 12/19/2019 and feels a 6-bed facility is appropriate. Councilmember Ernesto Gutierrez inquired if the Council can approve less than 12-beds. City Attorney Vail responded that the City Council will have to approve or deny the existing CUP which is for 12-beds. A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Gregory and seconded by Councilmember Carnevale to approve the Conditional Use Permit No. 19-008; and, direct Staff to send letters to the licensing agencies, regarding the following concerns: • size of bedrooms and common areas • access to restrooms • preparation of food and food storage M.O. 2019-164 A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Gregory and seconded by Councilmember Carnevale to approve the It is requested that the Mayor and City Council Members conduct a public hearing to consider a de novo review of Planning Commission approval of Conditional Use Permit No. 19-008 to allow a Congregate Living Health Facility for up to 12 beds within an existing single family residential dwelling in the R1 Zoning District. RESULT: APPROVED [3 TO 2] MOVER: Raymond Gregory, Mayor Pro Tem SECONDER: Mark Carnevale, Councilmember AYES: Mark Carnevale, John Aguilar, Raymond Gregory NAYS: Ernesto Gutierrez, Rita Lamb C. CFD 2006-1, IA #12, Formation, Election and Ordinance Public Hearing Recommendation: For City Council to: 1) Hold a Public Hearing on the (a) formation of Improvement Area No. 12 of the City of Cathedral City Community Facilities District No. 2006-1 (Law Enforcement, Fire, Paramedic and General Maintenance Services), and (b) levy of special taxes. 2) Adopt the following resolutions: (a) Resolution determining the validity of prior proceedings and establishing the Improvement Area No. 12 of the City of Cathedral City Community Facilities District No. 2006-1 (Law Enforcement, Fire, Paramedic and General Maintenance Services). (b) Resolution calling a special election within Improvement Area No. 12 of the City of Cathedral City Community Cathedral City Page 12 Printed on 12/19/2019 Facilities District No. 2006-1 (Law Enforcement, Fire, Paramedic and General Maintenance Services). 3) Hold Election. 4) Adopt the Resolution canvassing the results of the election held within Improvement Area No. 12 of the City of Cathedral City Community Facilities District No. 2006-1 (Law Enforcement, Fire, Paramedic and General Maintenance Services). 5) Conduct First Reading of the Ordinance authorizing the levy of a special tax within Improvement Area No.12 of the City of Cathedral City Community Facilities District No. 2006-1 (Law Enforcement, Fire, Paramedic and General Maintenance Services). Mayor John Aguilar opened the Public Hearing on the (a) formation of Improvement Area No. 12 of the City of Cathedral City Community Facilities District No. 2006-1 (Law Enforcement, Fire, Paramedic, Park and General Maintenance Services), and levy of special taxes. Tracey Martinez, City Clerk, stated that the Notice of Public Hearing has been published in accordance with the Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act of 1982 and proof of such publication is on file in the City Clerk's office. Tami Scott, Director of Administrative Services, presented the following information: • Community Facilities District 2006-1 • FIR-Scope & Methodology • Process to Form Improvement Zone within District • Improvement Zones Annexed Mayor John Aguilar asked if there are any oral protests of comments from the public. Councilmember Ernesto Gutierrez inquired if there is an expiration and??? Tami Scott responded that there is no expiration. Councilmember Rita Lamb requested clarification on the levy of special tax and Mello-Roos. Tami Scott gave an overview of the levy of special tax and Mello-Roos. Mayor Pro Tem Raymond Gregory requested clarification on what areas qualify for this type of district. Tami Scott gave an overview of the qualifications. Cathedral City Page 13 Printed on 12/19/2019 Mayor John Aguilar stated that if there are any homeowners subject to the proposed special tax wishing to file a written protest shall file with the City Clerks. Seeing none, he closed the Public Hearing. M.O. 2019-165 A motion was made by Councilmember Gutierrez and seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Gregory to approve the For City Council to: 1) Hold a Public Hearing on the (a) formation of Improvement Area No. 12 of the City of Cathedral City Community Facilities District No. 2006-1 (Law Enforcement, Fire, Paramedic and General Maintenance Services), and (b) levy of special taxes. 2) Adopt the following resolutions: (a) Resolution determining the validity of prior proceedings and establishing the Improvement Area No. 12 of the City of Cathedral City Community Facilities District No. 2006-1 (Law Enforcement, Fire, Paramedic and General Maintenance Services). (b) Resolution calling a special election within Improvement Area No. 12 of the City of Cathedral City Community Facilities District No. 2006-1 (Law Enforcement, Fire, Paramedic and General Maintenance Services). 3) Hold Election. 4) Adopt the Resolution canvassing the results of the election held within Improvement Area No. 12 of the City of Cathedral City Community Facilities District No. 2006-1 (Law Enforcement, Fire, Paramedic and General Maintenance Services). 5) Conduct First Reading of the Ordinance authorizing the levy of a special tax within Improvement Area No. 12 of the City of Cathedral City Community Facilities District No. 2006-1 (Law Enforcement, Fire, Paramedic and General Maintenance Services). RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Ernesto Gutierrez, Councilmember SECONDER: Raymond Gregory, Mayor Pro Tern AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb Motion A motion was made by Councilmember Gutierrez and seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Gregory to adopt a Resolution of the City Council of the City of Cathedral City determining the validity of prior proceedings, establishing Improvement Area No. 12 of the City of Cathedral City Community Facilities District No. 2006-1 (Law Enforcement, Fire, Paramedic, Park and General Maintenance Services). Reso 2019-47 Cathedral City Page 14 Printed on 12/19/2019 RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Ernesto Gutierrez, Councilmember SECONDER: Raymond Gregory, Mayor Pro Tern AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb Motion A motion was made by Councilmember Carnevale and seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Gregory to adopt a Resolution of the City Council of the City of Cathedral City acting on behalf of Improvement Area No. 12 of the City of Cathedral City Community Facilities District No. 2006-1 (Law Enforcement, Fire, Paramedic, Park and General Maintenance Services) calling a special election. Reso 2019-48 RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Mark Carnevale, Councilmember SECONDER: Raymond Gregory, Mayor Pro Tern AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb Motion A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Gregory and seconded by Councilmember Carnevale to adopt a Resolution of the City Council of the City of Cathedral City acting on behalf of Improvement Area No. 12 of the City of Cathedral City Community Facilities District No. 2006-1 (Law Enforcement, Fire, Paramedic, Park and General Maintenance Services) canvassing the results of the special election held within said District. Reso 2019-49 RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Raymond Gregory, Mayor Pro Tern SECONDER: Mark Carnevale, Councilmember AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb Motion A motion was made by Councilmember Carnevale and seconded by Councilmember Lamb to approve the first reading of an Ordinance of the City Council of the City of Cathedral City acting as the Legislative body of Community Facilities District No. 2006-1 (Law Enforcement, Fire, Paramedic, Park and General Maintenance Services) of the City of Cathedral City authorizing the levy of special tax within said District. M.O. 2019-166 Cathedral City Page 15 Printed on 12/19/2019 I RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Mark Carnevale, Councilmember SECONDER: Rita Lamb, Councilmember AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb D. Introduction and First Reading of an Ordinance Amending the City Subdivision Ordinance Recommendation: To hold a public hearing; introduce and provide first reading by title only; and waive further reading of an ordinance amending Riverside County Land Division Ordinance 460, adopted by reference by City Ordinance 12, to add new sections relating to the amendment of recorded final maps and parcel maps, and the use of lien contracts as subdivision improvement security. Paul Mangaudis, Senior Engineer, gave an overview of a proposed Ordinance amending the City Subdivision Ordinance and staff recommendation. Mayor John Aguilar opened the Public Hearing. Mayor John Aguilar asked if there are any members of the public wishing to speak. Seeing none, he closed the Public Hearing. M.O. 2019-167 A motion was made by Councilmember Gutierrez and seconded by Councilmember Carnevale to approve the To hold a public hearing; introduce and provide first reading by title only; and waive further reading of an ordinance amending Riverside County Land Division Ordinance 460, adopted by reference by City Ordinance 12, to add new sections relating to the amendment of recorded final maps and parcel maps, and the use of lien contracts as subdivision improvement security. RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Ernesto Gutierrez, Councilmember SECONDER: Mark Carnevale, Councilmember AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb 6. LEGISLATIVE ACTIONS A. Appointment to Public Arts Commission Recommendation: To make an appointment to the Public Arts Commission to fill one vacant seat on the Commission with a term continuing to June 30, 2020. M.O. 2019-168 A motion was made by Councilmember Carnevale and seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Gregory to approve the To make an appointment to the Public Arts Cathedral City Page 16 Printed on 12/19/2019 Commission to fill one vacant seat on the Commission with a term continuing to June 30, 2020. RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Mark Carnevale, Councilmember SECONDER: Raymond Gregory, Mayor Pro Tern AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb B. Contract for Services - Cathedral City Community Amphitheater Concession Stand Recommendation: To approve a contract for services with Kick Back Cinemas Cathedral City LLC to manage and operate the Cathedral City Community Amphitheater concession stand as a pilot program for one year. Christopher Parman, Community and Events Manager, gave an overview of the proposed contract for services with Kick Back Cinemas Cathedral City to manage and operate the Cathedral City Community Amphitheater concession stand as a pilot program for one year. Councilmember Mark Carnevale asked for clarification on the rights of other vendors to sell beverages and the menu that is exclusive in this contract. He also inquired whether or not private events would have the ability to use outside catering. Christopher Parman explained the exclusive rights as outline in the contract. Eric Vail, City Attorney responded that if it is the intent of the City Council to exclude private events from the exclusive rights of Kick Back Cinemas in the contract, there needs to be language added for clarification. Mayor John Aguilar concurs with City Attorney. Mayor Pro Tem Raymond Gregory concurs with City Attorney. He also suggested that language be added to allow outside vendors to come in if Kick Back Cinemas declines to open the concessions due to low attendance. Ted Hane, Mary Pickford Theaters, stated that their intention is to open the concession as much as possible and are ok if other vendors come in if they decline. Motion subject to the clarifications and amendments discussed by the Council. M.O. 2019-169 A motion was made by Councilmember Gutierrez and seconded by Councilmember Carnevale to approve the To approve a contract for services with Kick Back Cinemas Cathedral City LLC to manage and operate the Cathedral City Community Amphitheater concession stand as a pilot program for one year. Cathedral City Page 17 Printed on 12/19/2019 RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Ernesto Gutierrez, Councilmember SECONDER: Mark Carnevale, Councilmember AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb C. Contract Award to Hardy & Harper, Inc. for the Phase 6 Pavement Management Program Recommendation: To award a contract to Hardy & Harper in the amount of $1,720,000 for the Pavement Management Program (PMP), Phase 6; and, approve a fifteen percent (15%) contingency in the amount of $258,000 for any unforeseeable construction costs; and, approve $90,000 for design, survey, inspection and material testing; thereby, making the total encumbrance for this Project $2,068,000; and, authorize the Director of Engineering/Public Works to issue the Notice of Proceed and request bonds and insurance for the project; and, authorize the City Manager to execute the contract documents. Vince Lopez, Senior Analyst, gave an overview of the Phase 6 Pavement Management Program and the proposed contract with Hardy & Harper, Inc. Eric Vail, City Attorney, stated that if a City Council Member's property is located in a new pavement area or pavement maintenance area, there will not be a conflict of interest. (check video 3:00:00) M.O. 2019-170 A motion was made by Councilmember Gutierrez and seconded by Councilwoman Lamb to approve the To award a contract to Hardy & Harper in the amount of $1,720,000 for the Pavement Management Program (PMP), Phase 6; and, approve a fifteen percent (15%) contingency in the amount of $258,000 for any unforeseeable construction costs; and, approve $90,000 for design, survey, inspection and material testing; thereby, making the total encumbrance for this Project $2,068,000; and, authorize the Director of Engineering/Public Works to issue the Notice of Proceed and request bonds and insurance for the project; and, authorize the City Manager to execute the contract documents. RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Ernesto Gutierrez, Councilmember SECONDER: Rita Lamb, Councilmember AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb D. Approval of CVAG Cooperative Reimbursement Agreement for ATP Projects' Design Services Recommendation: To approve a Coachella Valley Association of Governments Cathedral City Page 18 Printed on 12/19/2019 (CVAG) Cooperative Reimbursement Agreement for Professional Design Services for five (5) Active Transportation Program (ATP) Projects; and, authorize the City Manager to execute the Agreement; and, approve a General Fund Budget Amendment in the not to exceed amount of $240,270.00 to the Engineering 100-156-8601- 0000 Professional and Technical Service Fund to fund the Agreement obligations. Paul Mangaudis, Senior Engineer, gave an overview of the proposed Coachella Valley Association of Governments (CVAG) Cooperative Reimbursement Agreement for Professional Design Services for Active Transportation Program Projects. Tauri Scott, Director of Administrative Services, gave an overview of the proposed General Fund Budget Amendment. Mayor Pro Tern Raymond Gregory stated that this is a great example of investing in our City and it will continue to make Cathedral City one of the best cities in the Valley. M.O. 2019-171 A motion was made by Councilmember Gutierrez and seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Gregory to approve the To approve a Coachella Valley Association of Governments (CVAG) Cooperative Reimbursement Agreement for Professional Design Services for five (5) Active Transportation Program (ATP) Projects; and, authorize the City Manager to execute the Agreement; and, approve a General Fund Budget Amendment in the not to exceed amount of $240,270.00 to the Engineering 100-156-8601-0000 Professional and Technical Service Fund to fund the Agreement obligations. RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Ernesto Gutierrez, Councilmember SECONDER: Raymond Gregory, Mayor Pro Tern AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb E. Cathedral City Community Amphitheater Fee Schedule and Hours Recommendation: To approve a resolution setting the fee schedule and hours of operation for the Cathedral City Community Amphitheater. Christopher Parman, Community and Events Manager, gave an overview on the Resolution setting the fee schedule and hours of operation for the Cathedral City Community Amphitheater. Councilmember Ernesto Gutierrez questioned if Rancho Mirage leases their amphitheater out to third party events. He also questioned if these fees can be adjusted in the future. Cathedral City Page 19 Printed on 12/19/2019 Mr. Parman responded that the City of Rancho Mirage only allows City events in their amphitheater. He also stated that the City Council has the ability to adjust the fees at any time. Reso 2019-50 A motion was made by Councilmember Gutierrez and seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Gregory to approve the To approve a resolution setting the fee schedule and hours of operation for the Cathedral City Community Amphitheater. RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Ernesto Gutierrez, Councilmember SECONDER: Raymond Gregory, Mayor Pro Tem AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb F. Hall of Flowers Trade Show Special Use Permit Recommendation: To approve Special Use Permit#19-025 with the attached conditions of approval; and conditioned upon the adoption of the Ordinance allowing temporary cannabis events with a Special Use Permit; and with an effective date corresponding to the Ordinance becoming effective. Stone James, Economic Development Director, gave an overview of the Hall of Flowers Trade Show Special Use Permit No. 19-025. Mayor Pro Tem Raymond Gregory inquired if alcohol will be sold during this event. He also inquired if the Restaurant Casa Blanca will be selling alcohol. Mr. James responded that there is no alcohol allowed in the event and the Casa Blanca Restaurant is outside the event boundary. Mayor John Aguilar inquired how the issue of odor will be addressed and will there be staff onsite to address any issues or complaints. Daniel Diamantstein, Applicant, was called to speak. Odor issues that exist in cultivation should not be a factor at this event. He stated that OMI Industries will be doing odor abatement. Brian McLaughlin, OMI Industries Inc, was called to speak. He gave the background of the company and an overview of the plan to do odor abatement at the proposed event using a 1200 CFM Vapor Phase Unit. He stated that there will be staff onsite should issues arise and wind will not be a factor. Local contractors opportunity to do some work for the event. Will you give locate construction companies the opportunity to bid on supplying some of the materials for the event. Mr. Diamantstein responded that he owns or rents the materials needed for the event. He stated that it is a common practice in the industry to work with the local unions for construction needs. He stated that they are not allowing any alcohol Cathedral City Page 20 Printed on 12/19/2019 I into the event and attendees will not be allowed to bring any alcohol back in from the Casa Blanca Restaurant. M.O. 2019-172 A motion was made by Councilmember Carnevale and seconded by Councilwoman Lamb to approve the To approve Special Use Permit #19-025 with the attached conditions of approval; and conditioned upon the adoption of the Ordinance allowing temporary cannabis events with a Special Use Permit; and with an effective date corresponding to the Ordinance becoming effective. RESULT: APPROVED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: Mark Carnevale, Councilmember SECONDER: Rita Lamb, Councilmember AYES: Carnevale, Aguilar, Gregory, Gutierrez, Lamb 7. CLOSED SESSION The City Council met in Closed Session during the Study Session portion of the meeting and will be reflected in the Study Session minutes of December 11, 2019. A. Conference with Labor Negotiator Pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.6 Agency Negotiator: Charles McClendon, City Manager Represented Employees: AFSCME - The American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees CCPOA - Cathedral City Police Officers Association CCPMA - Cathedral City Police Management Association CCPFA - Cathedral City Firefighters Association CCFMA - Cathedral City Fire Management Association B. Conference with Legal Counsel - Anticipated Litigation Pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(d)(2). Number of Potential Cases: Three ADJOURN Mayor John Aguilar adjourned the Regular Meeting of December 11, 2019, at 10:45 PM. M r, City of C: edral City City Clerk,G ity of athedral City _ I I'. ,_11 _ A gt - Cathedral City Page 21 Printed on 12/19/2019